Thoughts on Re-Rewriting My Novel’s First Chapter

Not the "re-re" I'm referring to, but like the Bajan beauty in her famous revenge video, I had to get tough on this chapter

Not the “re-re” I’m referring to, but like the Bajan beauty in her famous revenge video, I had to get tough on this chapter

Writing is rewriting.

So the popular, and unfortunately, all too true saying goes.

After working on the first draft my historical fiction trilogy for the better part of three years (with a long, six-year hiatus in between), I was ecstatic to finally get started on draft two of book #1 back in January of this year.

More than that, though, I was ecstatic to let people read a bit of my work; writer friends whose opinions I value, who would all praise me and tell me how brilliant a writer I am.

Yeah, that’s not what happened at all.

Rather, my esteemed writer friends told me my first chapter – which I’d already once rewritten from how it read in the first draft – had too much exposition, that the main character felt a bit flat, and that my sentences were too complex.

To the latter point especially, one person, whose opinion I particularly value, told me she couldn’t even make it to the end of the chapter.


The worst part was, they were right.  Even without the telltale of three different people giving essentially the same feedback, when I objectively re-examined my chapter (as objectively as I was able), I could see a re-rewrite was clearly in order.

The following are my reflections on the process:

1) Someone’s got to do it

We’ve all heard the joke: Procrastinators of the world unite!  Tomorrow.

In no aspect of my life, especially my writing life, do I put things off, instead generally following the opposite tack and scheduling everything to death.

Chapter oneBut the gulf between thinking about fixing chapter one and actually doing the work was a spacious one indeed.

That is to say, I put the task off for nearly three-and-half months.

Part of this was because, in a moment of enlightened self-awareness, I realized some of the feedback I’d received applied not only to chapter one but chapters two and three as well.

Another part was that in the course of revising the first chapter most recently, I’d read through it so many times, I lost all perspective on it.  It had become a track too well-worn in my mind to think beyond in order to move in a different direction.

Yet another part was the idea that I was supposed to be moving forward through my chapters, not backward.  Plus, I’d just taken another short vacation and didn’t immediately feel strong enough mentally and creatively to charge straight into the thick of a re-rewrite.

But the further I continued moving ahead, the more I needed a functional first chapter.  I needed to know which leads and threads I had to follow up on (as well as which I still needed to introduce) in subsequent chapters.

And so once I reached the end of chapter seven (the first division I made in my manuscript’s long, unwieldy Word document to improve its navigability), I went straight back to the beginning again.

2) Blind, but now I see

While reading my friends’ feedback on my chapter, cliché as it is to say, it truly did feel like a light suddenly switched on in my head.

Every problem they pointed out and every suggestion the offered as a solution made PERFECT SENSE to me.  It was literally like, “Of course the main character feels flat”, as if I’d known it all along, even when I clearly didn’t or else I would have done something about it the first time.

I often find this to be the case in writing – that I know something is wrong with it, but I can only see it through the eyes of another person.  I’ll understand the problem in theory, yet will have trouble recognizing the real-world application of it in my own writing.

Or maybe I actually do recognize the problem (at least on a subconscious level), but just try to sneak it past anyway, having convinced myself that it’s not so bad and no one will notice.

Maybe not only am I not a brilliant writer, I’m secretly a lazy one as well.

3) Diced vegetables

Regardless of whether I’m secretly lazy, I’m definitely impatient, both in real life and, evidently, in my writing.

While I managed to mostly avoid the dreaded infodump in my first chapter (mostly…), I still managed to overload the text with more backstory than was strictly necessary.

Why?  Because I wanted to get it out of the way quickly so I could focus on the actual story.

But the more I thought about this motivation when it came time for re-rewriting, the more wrong it felt.  My novel’s backstory is important.  It’s the reason the front story is of any significance to the characters (and hence, the reader) at all.

Chopped vegetablesBut exposition isn’t something to just heap on the reader’s plate like a sloppy microwave dinner that’s still frozen in the center.  Rather, it needs to be like mashed up vegetables hidden in the otherwise fun food you serve to a child.

It needs to be sliced and diced and served in bite-sized portions the precise moment the reader must consume it for the story to make sense.  All of these food references being to say that backstory, when handled with subtlety, does enrich in a story greatly.

4) Give me a hint

The goal of the first chapter, I’ve come to realize through all of this, isn’t to make the reader know all there is to know about your main character, or even most of it.

Rather, the goal is to make something happen that the main character can use to hint at what there is to know about him/her.  That’s it: just an incident or event that is exciting to read that involves main character acting and reacting in keeping with his/her personality.

It doesn’t have to reveal the full significance of the book’s central conflict, or even fully introduce it.  It just has to hint at it – to make the reader ask questions that can only be answered by continuing to read.

5) Say it shorter

It occurred to me over the course of this exercise that I write in something of a stream of consciousness.

Run-on sentence

It’s a bird, it’s a plane, no it’s…

Not like James Joyce or anything, but to the extent that I regularly lose track of the beginning of my sentences the further along I progress in them.

As a result, I end up with sentences that take an eternity to end because I’ve forgotten how many other details – offset by numerous commas and dashes – I’ve already included in them.

(This is a consequence of the way I create outlines, both for fiction and nonfiction, which are even more stream-of-consciousness, generally featuring no narrative pause any stronger than a semicolon.)

I’ve always known this to be a problem of mine, but I never fully grasped just how much of a problem.  Until one of my writer friends actually demonstrated it by marking up a sentence of mine.  It contained, she concluded, 12 different pieces of information.

In my re-revision, I thus ripped my sentences apart at the seams and recreated almost every single one.

After composed each new sentence, I then reread it, told myself to try writing it shorter, whether it strictly needed it or not, and then took another crack at simplifying it.

As complex and convoluted sentences has been my natural bent for so long, “Write it shorter” has become my new grammatical mantra – one that I’m hoping continuous repetition will someday transform into instinctive action.


One more RiRi pic, because this is how boss I feel after overcoming this writing challenge

One more RiRi pic, because this is how boss I feel after overcoming this writing challenge

If I sound at all demoralized by this experience, I actually feel quite the opposite.

As I’ve expressed previously, giving my work to other writers to critique was an incredibly humbling and edifying experience that I believe has irrevocably changed me as a writer.

Best of all, I’m happy to report my re-rewritten chapter one was a hit. “Your changes have made the writing quite strong”, the writer who previously couldn’t get through the pages informed me.


This doesn’t mean I believe this version is perfect, or that the remainder of this draft won’t contain additional flaws.  But I do feel like this process has set me on a definitive path I can follow for both the rest of the novel and many future chapter ones to come.

Do you struggle with first chapters?  What tips do you have for making them more effective?  Tell me about it in the comments.

(Image source #1, #3, #4, and #5; #2 – J.G. Noelle)

16 thoughts on “Thoughts on Re-Rewriting My Novel’s First Chapter

  1. Congratulations on doing the work! It’s hard to take what you’ve slaved over and rework it, but you did it!

    First chapters and I have reached an understanding. They can be as screwy as they want to be but I will write them and move on and then I will go back and tear them to shreds once I’ve finished. Personally, I write action first and fill in backstory as it comes along, so there’s practically no “setting up” that’s not done inside the action. I used to to the whole old-fashioned preface and then long, slow set up of a first chapter but none of those beauties survived the red pen.


    • Sounds like you figured it out through trial and error and practice and by having more than one novel to your name. Since this is only my first one (technically, my second, but that first one is buried in the bowels of my hard drive), I’m still learning how all of this is done. Ironically, I think my shelved novel had a stronger first chapter right out of the gate than this current one did, lol.

      Setting up inside the action is the key, I agree. I knew that in theory; I just had nowhere near the right balance between the too!

      Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you, Jess. You bring a tear to my eye. 🙂 It truly has taken a village to teach me how to compose proper sentences, with not the least of the contributions being from my graduate supervisor years ago. Whomever it was who said that scientist’s can’t write was making a gross generalization.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m rewriting the beginning of Book 2 – because I decided it needed a completely new scene – and that means asking the same structural questions you did: what leads do you start, how are things going to connect later, and what do I absolutely HAVE to put in here, and what should wait.

    I’d be fine, it’s almost done, except that life keeps tossing hand grenades, and I lose focus.

    I’ll get there – I know what I want (a repeat of the first scene of Book 1, only different). You ae not alone in pain.


    • Revision misery loves company. But in truth, I’m actually enjoying the act of rewriting so far. I find whipping the words and structure into shape and sense very satisfying. More and more, the story is becoming what I envisioned it to be, not what it unwittingly became through the imperfect translation process that drafting is.


  3. “To the latter point especially, one person, whose opinion I particularly value, told me she couldn’t even make it to the end of the chapter”

    I literally gasped and put my hand over my mouth. I think she could’ve phrased that another way. It was way harsher than needed.

    The good news is you have overcome the challenge. You saw your mistakes. and worked really hard to make them right. That is not an easy task, I’m so proud of you.

    Congratulations on your first chapter re-write.

    I’m one of those odd people that likes writing first chapters. I’m not saying they aren’t a challenge, just that they’re a challenge I enjoy.

    When I write I literally have only two objectives for the first chapter.

    1 – Introduce protagonist: give the readers a bit of insight into her/his personality.

    2. Show the world: If it’s a fantasy book, I need to show some fantasy elements. Show the reader why this book has been classified this genre.

    Other than that I don’t really focus on much else. People always say “start with action” but that is not universal advice. I prefer my reader to get to know my character and see a glimpse into this world, THEN it’s time to bring on the action.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It was way harsher than needed.
      And it was over EMAIL, no less, even though we live in the same city and see each other often, lol.

      Seriously, though, it wasn’t that bad coming from her. She’s my writer bff and CP and we have the trust in our friendship for her to tell me something like that. I’d previously read her first chapter (she had to rewrite hers 3-4 times as well) and given her tough feedback, so we’d already established the extent to which we weren’t going to mince words.

      This isn’t to say it wasn’t still hard to take, but better coming from a friend than an agent or publisher. We laugh about it now in a self-deprecating sort of way that’s edged in denial that it even really happened. I’m sure we will have many more harsh comments for each other as we move forward in our respective revisions.

      I like your two objectives for the first chapter; they are pretty much the conclusion I eventually arrived at over the course of 3.5 drafts of mine. When I hear “start with action”, I interpret that as, not necessarily a car chase or a murder, but rather just the opposite of inaction.

      My very first draft of chapter one had the main character expositing poetically about her life, but nothing actually happened until page 5. My strategy this time was to show both character and things happening at the same time, from the very first page.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Well I’m glad that you have someone you can be 100% honest with and can do the same in return, that’s great.

        I’m so excited for you, the new strategy of showing character and things happening sounds great. You got this. You’ve learnt from your mistakes and you’ve got this.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.